WARNING. THIS POST WILL HAVE BREAKING DAWN SPOILERS. DO NOT READ THIS IF YOU DON’T WISH TO GET SPOILED. THIS IS YOUR ONLY WARNING.
Anyway, my thoughts. To be blunt, I didn’t like Breaking Dawn. Granted I just finished it about 20 minutes ago and I’m rushing to get out a somewhat coherent copy of my first impressions, but I doubt my opinion of the book will change even after a reread.
The very first thing I didn’t like about it was the sex. There were way too many hinted nights where Bella and Edward had sex. It made it seem like the only reason they got married was to have an excuse that they could have sex. Especially in the first half, I was wincing whenever it got close to nighttime because half the time there was something that Bella would say that implied sex, or something of the sort. If I’m wrong ignore me – I have a rather short term memory. I know technically they are a married couple now and they can do what they want and yada yada, but Bella is still a teenager, without a college degree and without a job. I also didn’t like how she turned away all thoughts of pregnancy just because Edward was a vampire. I mean, he is still a guy with guy …functions that don’t change just because he’s lived for a century.
Which leads me on to my next irritation – the baby. It just made me cringe at how, well, perfect she was. “Renesmee” was a bit of a Mary Sue if I do say so myself, with her beautiful appearance and her ability to act as mature as a young adult even though she was what, three/four months old by the end of the book? Vampire or no, it’s extremely hard for me to imagine someone not even a year old communicating effectively to others in not one but TWO ways, understanding what others have to say, and being able to interpret feelings. It was a bit unreal to me, especially after reading about her thirst and how much blood Bella had to drink in order to satisfy it. She nearly killed Bella while inside the womb and then she comes out and is absolutely harmless and adorable and mature? What on earth?
Next point of irritation – Jacob. Imprinting on the baby. WTF?! To me this seemed like a very convenient excuse for Edward to accept Jacob and for Bella to stop being torn about him. He and Bella were both taken by surprise when Quil imprinted on Claire, but now he imprints on an infant and everything’s all nice and dandy after a short confrontation between him and Bella. To make things worse, not much is said about how Jacob feels about this imprint. I know it probably would have just been something along the likes of how Bella/Edward are described, but I was curious to see how he felt about imprinting on a newborn child.
Which leads me to my next point – the complete lack of werewolf/vampire rivalry in the second half. One thing that always kept me on my toes through the other books was the feelings that these two supernatural beings had for the other. Now, suddenly all those feelings disappear with Jacob imprinting on a baby, because taking away the person someone’s imprinted on isn’t allowed. So instead of harsh feelings between each other, everyone’s all friends towards the end of the book, and that seems to be wonderfully accepted. Even when the other vampires come to the Cullen’s, there is not one thread of animocity between the two groups when before it seemed like had a vampire/werewolf come within a mile radius of another there would be some feuding. The whole werewolf pack is just lounging around on the yard for part of the book. Gahhh.
Probably the thing that annoyed me the most was the letdown at climaxes. Jacob breaking away from Sam’s pack and forming his own – I expected there to be a nice werewolf showdown after that, or at least something more than a “Okay lets just let Jacob/Seth/Leah run around with the vampires a bit, even though we wanted to kill the vampires two seconds ago, and decide a new plan for getting rid of the Cullens – OH WAIT JACOB IMPRINTED ON ONE OF THEM? Never mind, we can’t do that anymore! Let’s go chill and make peace.” Honestly, that was a big climatic letdown for me. And to make things worse, the whole resolvement between Jacob’s pack and Sam’s pack was explained in about two sentences. I know the reasons for the resolvement make sense, but seriously that had to be the biggest climatic dupe of my life.
The other climatic letdown was the Volturi meetup at the end. I was all pumped for the biggest vampire/werewolf showdown in history, especially since Meyer made such a big point about Carlisle and the others finding witnesses to prove Renesmee was innocent. I mean, that basically took up a good fifty page chunk of the book. Bella and Edward were constantly stressed, and Bella was so worried about Alice and the cryptic messages she left behind. Everyone was pretty much in panic mode, and Bella was just learning about her new skill of “shielding” she had and was trying to somewhat get it to expand, but she was having such a hard time, and then GUESS WHAT?! The Volturi arrive, and BAM Bella gets blazing mad and magically gets complete power over this skill she was struggling so hard over a day ago. Not to mention all these skills that the Volturi have, which when Edward described them sounded rather frightening, are all brilliantly repelled by Bella’s shield and no one is hurt. And then in what would have been the big epic battle scene, there is nothing but some talking, a resolvement, and peace, which was a very very big letdown. I mean at least in the other books there was some sort of action! But in Breaking Dawn, there was nothing but waaay too much built-up anticipation which led to ….nothing.
Overall I would give Breaking Dawn 2/5 stars. There were too many conveniences that occurred so that everyone could have a happy ending. Jacob imprinting, Alice showing up at the showdown between the Volturi and the Cullen’s with a half-vampire she just so HAPPENED to find, Bella suddenly getting control over her shield, Renesmee getting born and being an angel, etc etc. It seemed like Meyer was just pushing for a way to have everything be nice and calm and happy, so she threw in whatever she could that, while still making sense, would lead to nice resolutions. That, to me, is what brought the book down. Don’t call me emo for not liking happy resolutions – I do to some extent, as long as they’re real and possible. The happy resolutions in Breaking Dawn did not seem at all possible to me before reading the book. I had been spoiled about Edward/Bella having a kid and Jacob imprinting on it a few days before Breaking Dawn released, and I had really hoped that they were false (even though I knew they were true because I trusted the poster of them). But no, it was all true.
One big letdown indeed. Breaking Dawn was far from what I had hoped and expected the book to be.