Warning: this post has spoilers about the movie. Yea.
—————-
After watching all the HBP trailers, I was pretty certain that it would actually be a decent movie. Boy was that the wrong mindset to have while walking into the theater.
To sum it up, HBP sucked. The movie was too centered around romance and had random plot points thrown in here and there to attempt to make a coherent storyline (that didn’t work btw). There were too many parts that were left out that could have been kept in from the book (example: Dumbledore’s funeral could have totally replaced that wand holding thing).
Before I get into all the bad things from the movie, let me try to think of a few good things. Uhh…. well there was one particular line that was quite good only because it reminded everyone in GSET of an inside joke (“Indeed.” -Snape). Slughorn was portrayed pretty well too. I also really enjoyed seeing Quidditch again, even if it was extremely brief, though that’s probably my OQL geeky side coming out. Luna was brilliant as usual (go Evanna Lynch!). I also felt that Michael Gambon did a somewhat better job as Dumbledore this time. He actually seemed a little more caring than in the previous movies (especially compared to OOTP). …And I think that’s all I really liked.
The major issue I had with HBP is that everything was a plot point, except for the romance. I know usually in the HP movies things are put in as plot points, but in HBP it felt like this aspect was extremely stressed to the point where there was nothing else in the movie except obvious plot devices and crappy romance. Here everyone says “but the romance showed how they grew up, so it was crucial!” Yes, there obvious was going to be some romance because it was also a part of the books, but there was too much. Practically every scene included a hint of if not romance itself, and the emphasis of HBP was not on romance, but on Harry learning how to defeat Voldemort. The memories and the cave scene at the end were both pretty well done (forgot to add that to my like list, oh well), but it didn’t really flow well with the rest of the movie because the rest of the movie was practically all romance. Plus the Harry/Ginny kiss scene failed. “Close your eyes” …..um yea ok, and I thought the Cho/Harry kiss was bad. This surpassed it.
Don’t even get me started on the end either. Could it be any more corny? I know I have a biased opinion on the movie because I grew up being an HP fan, but still, EVERY single HP movie has probably ended with “we’re best friends, let us stick together!” *epic facepalm*
Dumbledore’s death was ok. I wasn’t excepting a lot because I knew the funeral would be cut out, but I felt they could have done a little more with it. Dumbledore was a pretty important character who lasted for six movies; he’s supposed to be the greatest wizard, and he was such a key character in the series. He could have been acknowledged at least a little more, but ah well.
The attack on the burrow was also eh. It could have been left out, but I realize that it was needed to provide more emphasis on the fact that the wizarding world is in danger and sacrifices will have to be made.
I like how Draco always wore a suit. And how Fenrir Greyback was never explained. I heard several people saying how they were confused about him after the movie.
Oh yes, one more thing: Ginny kicks major ass in Quidditch. Bonnie Wright is awesome. Add that to the like list too.
Sorry that my thoughts are all over the place. It’s 1:30 in the morning, and I’m pretty tired, but there you go, all my first impressions of the movie. Overall I’d say it was an ok movie but a horrible adaptation of the book. Too much romance brought down the movie in my opinion. However, watching it with GSET was pretty awesome.
Note: This is all my opinion. If you have a different opinion, feel free to post it. I’ll gladly argue.